About This Spot

Pizza Carrello arrives like a familiar friend in Gillette—a spacious, warm refuge where time unfolds with easy conversation and the comforting crackle of a wood-fired oven. Whether you’re stepping in after a long day or settling in for a leisurely meal with company, the open layout invites you to relax without feeling rushed. Natural light spills through the windows, and the gentle hum of lively chatter sets a welcoming tone that’s both vibrant and unpretentious.

The atmosphere strikes a thoughtful balance: it’s casual enough for a midweek dinner yet lively enough to gather a crowd on game night, even if it quietly beckons for a few more screens to fully sparkle into a sports hub. The staff move with warmth and care that echoes through the room, helping guests feel tended to without ceremony. It’s this thoughtful attentiveness paired with the inviting space that makes Pizza Carrello more than just a stop for a meal—it’s a place where moments accumulate naturally.

At the heart of the experience is the kitchen’s open fire, lending an honest, smoky scent to every dish that emerges. The pizzas carry a signature crispness to their crusts, layered with thoughtful toppings that hint at both creativity and tradition. From the playful spice of a firecracker-inspired pie to the sweet surprise of a dessert pizza, each offering feels like a small discovery. The menu also weaves in comforting sides and unique appetizers, pairing perfectly with a cold, crisp beer or a smooth cold brew, crafting an experience that’s both familiar and quietly adventurous.

Communal and flexible, this is a place where a group of friends can share plates without pressure, and families can carve out their own little celebrations amid the buzz. It’s no surprise that pizza lovers who travel from afar find something quietly memorable here, drawing them back again, as the balance of good food and understated joy lingers with you long after the last slice.

What’s Available Here

  • IconIdentifies as women-owned
  • IconOutdoor seating
  • IconDelivery
  • IconTakeaway
  • IconDine-in
  • IconFast service
  • IconGreat beer selection
  • IconGreat cocktails
  • IconGreat dessert
  • IconGreat wine list
  • IconServes local specialty
  • IconLunch
  • IconDinner
  • IconSolo dining
  • IconWheelchair-accessible car park
  • IconWheelchair-accessible entrance
  • IconWheelchair-accessible seating
  • IconWheelchair-accessible toilet
  • IconAlcohol
  • IconBeer
  • IconCocktails
  • IconCoffee
  • IconComfort food
  • IconHappy-hour drinks
  • IconHappy-hour food
  • IconHealthy options
  • IconLate-night food
  • IconQuick bite
  • IconSmall plates
  • IconSpirits
  • IconVegan options
  • IconVegetarian options
  • IconWine
  • IconBrunch
  • IconLunch
  • IconDinner
  • IconCatering
  • IconDessert
  • IconSeating
  • IconTable service
  • IconBar on site
  • IconToilet
  • IconCasual
  • IconCosy
  • IconTrendy
  • IconFamily friendly
  • IconGroups
  • IconLGBTQ+ friendly
  • IconTourists
  • IconTransgender safe space
  • IconUniversity students
  • IconCheques
  • IconCredit cards
  • IconDebit cards
  • IconNFC mobile payments
  • IconCredit cards
  • IconGood for kids
  • IconHigh chairs
  • IconKids' menu
  • IconFree of charge street parking
  • IconFree parking lot
  • IconParking
  • IconDogs allowed outside

Location & Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Wednesday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Thursday Closed
Friday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Saturday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Sunday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Guest Reviews

Faith Lorenz 24 Dec 2025

Good service. Food and dessert were excellent, I wished I had room for more! Highly recommend.

Joseph Bales 12 Dec 2025

Ordered 3 different pizzas. They were all great. Tried chicken pizza with BBQ sauce on the side because I'm not big on BBQ pizza. It was fantastic! Sauce is more vinegar based and ended up being my favorite. Place is a wide open space but only 2 tvs at the bar. I could see groups coming in for sports and staying a long while if they had more tvs to cater to that crowd. Great service too! Maybe my review is because I had a couple great beers? Definitely going back!

Samantha Coleman 09 Dec 2025

My husband and I flew into Wyoming from WA State and we found this pizza to be highly superior to anything we've had back home. This is a wonderful experience. Their pizza ovens are in full view and the staff was hands down so wonderful. Beer was crisp and cold. We will be back in our next visit!

Christ Endeavors Ministry 29 Nov 2025

What a Gem in Gillette, this place is incredible huge in size, took care of our party of 12, and the Pizza is absolutely incredible! I'll say definitely in my top 3 the crust and toppings were delicious and the desert pizza was out of this world!!! Highly recommend!!!

Debbie Mestas 03 Nov 2025

My teacher recommended Pizza Carrello when I asked about a good place to eat in Gillette. It wasn't very busy when we got there but was rapidly filling up when we left. Our server was excellent and when I asked what she would recommend, she suggested several pizzas and we chose A Pizza My Heart which was delicious! We also chose Herb's Heavenly Little Sins for dessert. They were absolutely amazing! I think next time I go there I will order them again. Our server was excellent as was our meal and we had a very positive experience! If you are looking for great pizza, I would recommend Pizza Carrello.

Cassandra Burch 31 Oct 2025

Pizza Carrillo never disappoints! I’ve been here many times and the food is always delicious. This was my boyfriend’s first time, and he can attest that everything had amazing flavor, unique combos and outstanding service. From the tasty brick oven pizza to the freshly made pasta, there was no shortage in bold flavor and perfectly curated textures. Our waitress, Kloi was attentive, friendly and we would highly recommend she serve you during your visit. 10/10 will come again!

Meredith Van Zuiden 20 Sep 2025

The food and drinks were amazing! We had a great server, Janice, and we will be coming back any chance we have.

Share Your Experience
Related Listing

Recently Viewed Listing

4.3
1336 Reviews

Naati Cafe

56, 1st A Main Rd, KHB Colony, 7th Block, Koramangala, Bengaluru, Karnataka 560095, India
4.7
733 Reviews

North of Bourbon

935 Goss Ave, Louisville, KY 40217, United States
4.3
181 Reviews

Ganapati Foods

705 First St, Rockville, MD 20851, United States
4.4
454 Reviews

SOHO Sushi Burrito

6040 Badura Ave, Las Vegas, NV 89118, United States
4.7
258 Reviews

Tazza Kitchen

Thornbury Centre, 79 Leeds Old Rd, Bradford BD3 8JX, United Kingdom
Subscribr Now

Get All Updates & Advance Offers